I've been testing out the Voice Caddie for a couple months now. With all the driving around I do, I wanted to put it to the test and see how it works on a number of different courses.
Ironically, it didn't seem to find the course on the first place I played (Cottonwood-Ivanhoe in El Cajon), but has worked perfectly on every course since (Salt Creek, Yucaipa Valley, Calimesa, Summerly, Pechanga, Saticoy, Olivas, Los Amigos, Bayonet and Quail Lodge). When courses already have GPS in the carts, I didn't find much use for the VC other than just to test its accuracy. It was accurate to GPS measurements, sprinkler heads, etc. everywhere I went. In some cases, it will get confused as to which hole you are on (especially on a tight course layout where holes are closer together), but it's easy to manually adjust the hole.
On some courses, it comes in very handy. Beats stomping around in search of a sprinkler head or guessing how far you are in between the 100-150-200 posts on the edge of a fairway. I don't really like clipping it to my hat, so I have it clipped to my bag and it works fine for walking or riding. The voice on it is a little silly and I've gotten a few funny looks, so I've learned to be kind of discreet with it when playing with strangers.
It does what it claims to do, which is measure to the center of the green. Usually, that's all I'll really need and I can make my adjustments accordingly based on flag position, wind, etc. I'm not too anal about distances. Some more hardcore golfers who want exact yardage may be left wanting more from the Voice Caddie.
Otherwise, the main disadvantage of the Voice Caddie compared to a visually based GPS system is that it won't show you how far you have to a bunker or a hazard if you are deciding to lay-up, choose a place to aim off the tee or need to know how much to clear a trouble area. It has it's main function and it works well for that, but not much more. I haven't tried any of the trainer/tempo functions on it, but I don't think it could keep up with my swing anyway.
It's much better than nothing (especially on poorly marked courses), but does have its limitations compared to more detailed visual GPS devices. I am using it much more than I thought I would, so that's a plus.
» Close
